First as Tragedy, then as Farce

The Sunday Tribune reports that so bored are two-thirds of southern school children studying the north that a government report has recommended that comedians be used to engage their interest. I suspect that the authors of this report fail to realise the utter contempt that “interesting” lesson plans provoke amongst those subjected to them, but of more concern than the attitude of bored schoolchildren should be the attitude of the history teachers themselves. Among the reasons given for not wanting to teach the history of Northern Ireland by teachers was that they did not know enough about the subject.

I would like to say I’m stunned by this, but I’m not. It reflects the dominant attitude in the south over several decades, which was to try and ignore the north as far as possible. The report asks “If students do not learn about modern Irish history in a school context, will they be skilled enough to interpret what they see in the media outside school?” And “If in senior cycle, teachers are not supported to take on sensitive issues, are they abdicating an important duty to give impartial information on topics? If we wish to deal with post-conflict situations and empower upcoming generations, we cannot ignore the difficult and sensitive events that have impacted upon us”.
Ignoring the dereliction of professional duty inherent in the attitude of “I don’t know about that, so I’m not teaching it” (were they all experts on, say, Nazi Germany before they did the reading for teaching it?), this raises the question of what education is for, especially in a rapidly-changing society. The Republic, like the UK, France and elsewhere, been trying to deal with the question of educating children drawn from different cultural and religious traditions. In the North, we have seen the damage a badly-organised and divisive education system can wreak not only on individual children but on society as a whole.

Ireland, north and south, needs an education system that meets not just childrens’ educational needs, but also those of society. The education system is a powerful tool in shaping attitudes. As Ireland north and south becomes an increasingly diverse place, the education system must be changed to meet these needs. A secular and progressive education system teaching the virtues of equality has been one of the central planks of republican ideology throughout the world in the last few centuries. This is the model Ireland needs north and south. To teach children that all are equal, all part of the same community of citizens, with equal rights and common interests.

One of the great failures of the Blair government has been education. The promotion of faith schools, academies, and the abject failure to deal with the inequalities created by a massive private sector all condemn New Labour. As does its failure to live up to its rhetoric on citizenship classes, and its failure to inculcate an egalitarian vision. It is important that teachers in the Republic teach pupils about Northern Ireland, all the more so with the recent influx of immigrants. The consequences of prejudice, sectarianism, bigotry and hatred must be taught to all. Elsewhere, the paper reports on a school class with only one native child. The parallels of northern sectarianism with southern racism must be central to explaining to southern children why they must learn about the north. They are more likely to understand why the north is important when being taught in these terms than from watching Patrick Kielty torture his audience with the same old jokes.


4 Responses to “First as Tragedy, then as Farce”

  1. WorldbyStorm Says:

    Very much agree. One small thought re Blair, I can’t help but think that when it came down to it they had no governing approach on education and therefore their response was completely all over the shop. Everything seems to have been ad hoc to the extreme.

    In the South it’s even worse.

  2. garibaldy Says:

    Yeah it has been a mess in the UK. Ridiculous when you think about what a big deal was made of it. Stupidity of applying the market to state schools, added to a complete failure to try to integrate communities in the name of a vacuous multi-culturalism has resulted in a mess. To think that Blair was on really good terms with the Muslim community because of this. Shows how much things can change.

    The South is a joke too. Grind schools etc. Disaster zone. Puts all the rhetoric about a great education system in perspective. As do the stories about university cuts. No surprise there.

  3. WorldbyStorm Says:

    I think the basic problem is that centre leftists for too long have pushed equality off the table in education. They’re in thrall to this idea that somehow we can have a positive social outcome through effective chaos. But the opposite is correct. A state sector with a peripheral private sector that diminished rapidly is the way forward as I see it. But that would demand strong action…

  4. garibaldy Says:

    Couldn’t agree more. Equality has become a dirty word. The power of the private sector lobby in the UK is incredible, although plenty of the private schools are nowhere near the standard they should be. I think that no British government in the current climate will even begin to seriously tackle the issue. We need a climate along the lines of the post-war period, and even then it wouldn’t be all that easy. A good start though would be properly enforcing serious quotas at the top universities, thus taking away the advantage of going private. Can’t see anything happening in the south either. Which is why PSF’s total mishandling of the 11+ is such a disaster. What has to happen though is that any schools that try and go private get their buildings seized as the government paid for them. Cripple them with the debt of trying to pay for them, and they’ll stay in the state sector. I think though the grammars will survive and not go private.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: